Best Paper for Printing MTG Proxies: Complete Comparison

Choosing the right paper is crucial when printing MTG proxies. The wrong choice can result in flimsy cards, poor color quality, or cards that don't feel right in your hand. This guide compares all your options to help you make the best decision.

Understanding Paper Weight

Paper weight is measured in pounds (lb) or grams per square meter (gsm):

• Regular printer paper: 20-24lb (75-90gsm)
• Cardstock: 65-110lb (176-300gsm)
• Photo paper: Varies, typically 24-32lb (90-120gsm)

Heavier paper feels more like real Magic cards but may be too thick for some uses.

Option 1: Cardstock (Best for Standalone Cards)

Pros

• Feels closest to real cards - proper thickness and rigidity
• Durable - can be shuffled without sleeves
• Professional appearance - looks like actual trading cards
• No backing needed - works standalone

Cons

• More expensive than regular paper
• May be too thick for double-sleeving
• Requires heavier-duty printer for thick cardstock

Recommended Specifications

• Weight: 100-110lb (270-300gsm)
• Finish: Matte or semi-gloss
• Color: Bright white or off-white

Best Use Cases

• Cards you'll play without sleeves
• Display pieces or collection items
• When you want the most authentic feel

Option 2: Photo Paper (Best for Sleeved Play)

Pros

• Excellent color accuracy - vibrant, true-to-screen colors
• Good thickness - works well with the sleeve trick
• Multiple finishes available - matte, glossy, semi-gloss
• Affordable - cheaper than heavy cardstock

Cons

• Too thin standalone - needs backing for proper feel
• Glossy can be slippery - may slide in sleeves
• May curl if humidity changes

Recommended Specifications

• Weight: 24-32lb (90-120gsm)
• Finish: Matte (best for readability)
• Type: Premium photo paper

Best Use Cases

• Cards you'll play in sleeves
• When color accuracy is critical
• Budget-friendly option with good results

Option 3: Regular Printer Paper (Budget Option)

Pros

• Very affordable - cheapest option
• Works with sleeve trick - perfectly fine when backed
• Easy to find - available everywhere
• Lightweight - easy to store many cards

Cons

• Too thin - must use sleeve trick
• Lower color quality - colors may appear muted
• Less durable - tears easily if mishandled

Recommended Specifications

• Weight: 20-24lb (75-90gsm)
• Finish: Standard matte
• Brightness: 92+ brightness rating

Best Use Cases

• Testing decks before buying real cards
• Temporary proxies
• When printing many cards at once

Comparison Table

The Sleeve Trick: Making Thin Paper Work

If you choose photo paper or regular paper, the sleeve trick is essential:

1. Print your proxy on the thin paper
2. Cut it carefully to size
3. Place it in front of a real bulk common card
4. Insert both into a card sleeve

This method gives you perfect thickness and shuffle feel regardless of paper choice.

Special Considerations

Double-Faced Cards

For double-faced cards (like werewolves or transform cards):

• Use thinner paper (photo or regular) so both sides fit in a sleeve
• Print both sides separately and place back-to-back
• Or use a clear sleeve and flip as needed

Foil Proxies

To create foil-like effects:

• Use glossy photo paper for shine
• Some printers have "glossy" or "photo" modes
• Consider laminating with glossy laminate (adds thickness)

Color Accuracy

For best color matching:

• Use matte photo paper - reduces glare and shows true colors
• Calibrate your printer if possible
• Print a test card first to check colors

Where to Buy

Cardstock

• Office supply stores (Staples, Office Depot)
• Craft stores (Michaels, Hobby Lobby)
• Online: Amazon, specialty paper retailers

Photo Paper

• Office supply stores
• Electronics stores (Best Buy)
• Online retailers

Regular Paper

• Any office supply store
• Supermarkets
• Online in bulk

Final Recommendations

For most players: Start with matte photo paper (24-32lb). It offers the best balance of quality, cost, and usability with the sleeve trick.

For display pieces: Use 100lb cardstock for the most authentic feel and appearance.

For testing/budget: Regular printer paper works fine when combined with the sleeve trick.

Remember: The paper is just one part of the equation. Proper printer settings, cutting technique, and card design quality all contribute to the final result. Start with TCGCustom to create your card designs, then choose the paper that fits your needs and budget.